What a limping heat pump costs you between now and the repair
A heat pump that still runs but runs wrong doesn't feel like an emergency. It feels like a slightly higher bill, every single day, until it becomes one.

The arithmetic of waiting
Put it in plain terms. A heat pump with a weak capacitor, a dirty coil or a slow refrigerant leak still cools the house in a St. Augustine July. It just runs longer to do it, and FPL bills by the hour the compressor is on. A system working thirty percent harder than it should for the ninety days of peak summer adds a meaningful amount to each monthly bill, enough that over a season the extra electricity often costs more than the repair would have.
Then there is the other side of the ledger. A capacitor left weak takes the compressor with it eventually. A coil left dirty raises pressures until a joint lets go. A leak left alone starves the compressor of the oil that circulates with the refrigerant. Each of those turns a small, same-day repair into a large one, or into a replacement, and it does so on the hottest week of the year when every contractor in St. Johns County is behind.
So the decision is not “repair or don’t.” It’s “repair now for one price, or repair later for a bigger one plus a summer of higher bills.” Framed that way, the call is easy to make. Here’s what to check before you make it.

Five things to check before you call
- The thermostat. Mode set to cool or heat, not off or fan. Setpoint below the room temperature in summer. Fresh batteries if it takes them. A blank screen usually means the float switch in the drain pan tripped, which means water, which means a clogged drain line.
- The filter. Pull it. If light doesn’t pass through it, replace it and give the system an hour. In pollen season and with pets, a St. Augustine filter can load in three weeks.
- The breakers. Both the indoor and outdoor units have one. If one is tripped, reset it once. If it trips again, leave it off and call; a repeat trip is a compressor or a wiring fault, and resetting it repeatedly cooks the compressor.
- The outdoor unit. Is the fan turning? Is the coil choked with oak litter or palmetto fronds? Is there ice on the copper lines? Is the disconnect pulled, which happens after yard work and pressure washing more often than you’d think?
- The drain. Find where the condensate line exits the house. In summer it should drip steadily when the system runs. Dry outlet, running system, warm house: the line is blocked.
When to stop and pick up the phone
The list above handles the fixes that don’t need a truck. Stop at any of these and call:
- Ice on the lines or the indoor coil. Turn the system off, run the fan only, and let it thaw while you call. Running it iced can flood the air handler and damage the compressor.
- A breaker that trips a second time.
- Any burning or electrical smell at the air handler or the outdoor unit.
- A hum from the outdoor unit with no fan turning. That’s a failed capacitor or fan motor, and the compressor is overheating while it hums.
- Water on the floor around the air handler, or a stain on the ceiling under an attic unit.
- Short cycling: on for two minutes, off for three, over and over.
- Refrigerant lines you’d like to top off yourself. Don’t. Refrigerant handling takes certification, and gas added to a leaking system leaves with the leak.
Call for same-day heat pump repair
Our side of the repair
A Cook’s heat pump repair visit in St. Augustine follows a fixed sequence, because skipping a step is how a system comes back in two weeks with a different complaint.
- Confirm the complaint with the thermostat and the air handler before touching the outdoor unit.
- Electrical first. Capacitor microfarads, contactor contacts, wiring at the condenser, voltage at the disconnect. Summer lightning and salt air make these the most common failures in this market, and they’re the cheapest.
- Refrigerant circuit. Pressures and temperatures on both sides, superheat and subcooling. A charge that’s low gets a leak search, not a top-off.
- Airflow. Static pressure across the air handler, blower amp draw, coil condition. In the attic systems of St. Augustine Shores and St. Augustine South, collapsed flex duct masquerades as a weak heat pump constantly.
- Reversing valve and defrost. Specific to heat pumps and the reason a general AC technician sometimes misdiagnoses one. We verify the valve shifts and the defrost control behaves.
- The number. Diagnosis explained, repair price written, your decision. If the system is at an age and condition where replacement is the better buy, we say so and give a free estimate alongside the repair.
- The repair and the retest. Parts on the van cover the common failures for Lennox, Carrier, Bryant, Trane and most other brands we see here. The system runs under load and the readings from the diagnostic are taken again before we leave.
After we leave
The repair holds longer if the conditions that caused it change. We send every customer off with a short list specific to the house:
- Beachside and bayfront units from Vilano to Crescent Beach: rinse the outdoor coil with fresh water monthly. Salt is what killed the contactor.
- Houses under the oak canopy in Nelmar Terrace, Fullerwood Park and Lincolnville: clear leaf litter from the condenser every few weeks from February through April.
- Attic air handlers: a filter every month in summer, and a look at the drain outlet after heavy rain.
- Flood-street homes in Davis Shores and along the bayfront: call for an inspection after any tide that reaches the slab, before the next heating or cooling demand.
- Everyone: the fall and spring tune-ups, where most of the repairs on this page get found for less.
A maintenance agreement with Cook’s bundles those visits with priority scheduling; the office confirms the current terms. [[CONFIRM WITH JERRY]]
What St. Augustine callers ask about heat pump repair
How quickly can someone be in Davis Shores?
The run from the Palm Coast headquarters to the Bridge of Lions is about 39 minutes without traffic, and Davis Shores is just across it. On a summer afternoon with the bridge up and tourists on the bayfront, add a few minutes. We dispatch around the clock, so the answer is usually the same day and often within hours.
Is a Saturday night call priced differently from a weekday?
No. Cook’s has no after-hours charge. The repair price for a failed contactor at 9 p.m. on a Saturday is the price for the same repair at 9 a.m. on a Wednesday.
Should I keep putting money into a fourteen-year-old heat pump?
For a small part, yes, once. For a compressor, a coil or a refrigerant leak at that age, the repair is usually a down payment on the next failure. We’ll put the repair price next to a replacement estimate with the FPL rebate applied and let you compare them in dollars rather than in our opinion.
Does the refrigerant type change what a repair will cost me?
It can. Systems from the 2000s run on a refrigerant that’s being phased down and getting more expensive each year, so a leak repair on one of those costs more in gas than the same repair on a current system. Units older than that may be on a refrigerant that’s scarce enough to make the math lean hard toward replacement. The data plate tells us which you have.
The unit took saltwater in last fall's king tide and seemed fine. Should I worry?
Yes, a little. Brackish water in the electrical compartment starts corrosion that fails a contactor or a board months later, usually on the first hot or cold stretch. A post-flood inspection is cheap compared to a compressor that burns out from a corroded contactor.
Other services in St. Augustine
- A/C ServicesRepair, maintenance and replacement for every age of house in St. Johns County.
- A/C RepairDiagnosis you can read, a price before the work, no surcharge after dark.
- A/C MaintenanceTwice-a-year tune-ups timed to this climate, with the coil cleaned and the drain cleared.
- A/C InstallationLennox systems sized for your house, installed any day of the week, FPL rebates handled.
- ThermostatsInstallation, replacement and the wiring fixes that make a thermostat actually work.
- GeothermalGround-source heat pumps for St. Johns County lots, with a clear decision path for older systems.
- Heating ServicesHeat pumps, electric furnaces and gas furnaces repaired, maintained and replaced across St. Johns County.
- Heat PumpThe one system that heats and cools a St. Johns County building, installed, repaired and maintained by Cook's.
- Heat Pump MaintenanceSpring and fall heat pump tune-ups built for St. Johns County humidity, salt and storms.
- Heat Pump InstallationLennox heat pumps sized by load calculation, installed in a day, FPL rebate handled.
- Furnace RepairElectric and gas furnace repair across St. Johns County, with the diagnosis explained and priced first.
- Furnace MaintenanceA November furnace check for electric, gas and dual-fuel heat, before the first cold front.
- Furnace InstallationGas, electric and dual-fuel furnaces installed in St. Johns County, with the heat pump alternative laid out honestly.
- Air QualityHumidity control, filtration, purification and ventilation for St. Johns County homes, measured before anything is sold.
- Indoor Air QualityFiltration, purification, humidity control and ventilation, chosen by a decision tree rather than a sales pitch.
- Duct CleaningDuct cleaning and sealing for St. Johns County homes, with the attic and crawlspace problems that cause the mess addressed too.
- CommercialRepair, maintenance and installation for St. Johns County storefronts, offices, restaurants and clinics, around the clock.
Running, but not right?
Call {{short_name}}. Diagnosis, a written price, and the fix the same visit when the part's on hand.